I definitely did not have sub-$70,000 bitcoin on my bingo card for this point in the year. Last week I said I increasingly thought we had seen the bottom. That call has not aged well. Hot inflation, higher yields, forced liquidations, and a tech selloff give us plenty of explanations to choose from. Nvidia was down 26.6% over the month through Thursday's close, so bitcoin getting caught in the same risk reduction is hardly shocking. Still, if you bought near the 2021 top and have held for five years, being told to zoom out is getting pretty fucking old.
At a bitcoin price of $69,118.89 on Friday morning, buying at the November 13, 2021 daily close would have produced a five-year gross return of just 7.3%, or 1.4% annually. That is abysmal, even before inflation. Move the starting date forward one year and the picture changes completely: a four-year holder is up 324%, or 43.5% annually. The three-year return is 89.5%, or 23.7% annually. The two-year and one-year returns are negative 23.6% and 30.6%, respectively. Entry price matters, and five years is a long time to wait for a result that has barely moved in nominal dollars.
This made me want to test the dollar-cost-averaging argument. Suppose you started with $100 and bought another $100 on the 13th of every month, using Coinbase daily closing prices, with the last purchase in October and everything valued at Friday morning's price. Over five years, $6,000 contributed would be worth about $9,732, a 62.2% gain on contributions and a 19.4% annualized money-weighted return, which accounts for when each contribution was invested. The four-year version turns $4,800 into $6,931, a 44.4% gain and an 18.6% annualized return. Consistently buying through the ugly periods made a substantial difference for someone who started near the last cycle's top.
The shorter windows are less comforting. The three-year DCA is down 4.4%, the two-year down 20.0%, and the one-year down 8.6%. Their annualized money-weighted returns are -2.9%, -19.9%, and -15.4%, respectively. Regular buying can leave you underwater in the short term, but every rolling four-year monthly DCA window I checked, using daily price history back to September 2014, ended in profit. I still think accumulating bitcoin steadily from income makes sense for a long-term saver. It removes the need to get one heroic entry decision right. This week's math also makes clear that patience has to be real, the money has to be money you can afford to leave alone, and nobody gets to promise you a profitable exit on your preferred schedule.